The power, and adverse effects, of immunotherapy (ACP 2022)
With great power comes great immunogenicity. Learn about the ins and outs of immunotherapy–its indications, its power, and its adverse effects–in this episode with Dr. Christian Cable, hematologist/oncologist and medical educator extraordinaire. We learn a riveting history of immunotherapy and about how checkpoint inhibitors work, as well as the best practices for identifying downstream effects of checkpoint inhibitors and their immune system activation (it’s all about the -Itis!).
Visit curbsiders.vcuhealth.org to claim CME credit for this episode.
Learn more or apply at scpmgphysiciancareers.com
Visit Locumstory.com to find out more about locum tenens.
Immunotherapy tries to turn on the immune system to recognize cancer. Cancers have evolved to be able to evade the immune system, by turning off specific signals that immune cells use to recognize cancer cells. Immunotherapy tries to turn these signals back on, in order to recognize a cancer as “bad” or “other”, and to be able to selectively attack that cancer. In Dr. Cable’s words, immunotherapy harnesses the body’s own natural defenses to get rid of the cancer.
The side effect profile is different from traditional chemotherapy, without severe nausea and vomiting, the hair loss, and generally without the same risk of infection. The challenge can be to have the immunotherapy target only the cancer cells and not normal cells. When this goes awry, you can get a variety of adverse effects that affect different parts of the body.
Sometimes, we learn about how things work–about the mechanism underlying an effect–long after we identify that effect. The history of immunotherapy begins in the late 19th century, when William Coley, a surgeon, noted that patients with cancer had remissions when they developed Streptococcus pyogenes infections. He tried to infect patients to treat their cancer–and though these patients suffered the consequences of an infection, their tumor burden did actually shrink some of the time. This proved to be somewhat effective for sarcoma, lymphoma, and testicular carcinoma. But there was no understanding of the mechanism through which this response occurred. (For more, read A Brief History of Immunotherapy).
Next, radiotherapy took the stage (alongside surgery) in the mid-century. Radiation oncologists noticed that you could radiate a tumor at one site and cause a distant, untreated tumor, or metastasis, to shrink. This is called the abscopal effect, the mechanism of which was somewhat unclear–now thought to founded in the release of tumor fragments from radiation-induced damage. These tumor fragments may awaken the immune system to its presence, both locally at the site of the radiation and more distantly, and allow the immune system to activate against the tumor. This is not dissimilar to vaccination–in which a microbial antigen is injected to provoke an immune response and immune memory, not just at the site of antigen-exposure but throughout the body.
And don’t forget bone marrow stem cell transplant, initially introduced in 1957 (check out the 1957 NEJM article by Thomas et al.) to treat bone marrow failure from radiation exposure and then quickly expanded to attempt to treat blood cancers. Yet, the mechanism behind this–and the existence of HLA matching, and the power of someone else’s T-Cells to recognize your leukemia–didn’t begin to be understood until years later.
And so, as scientists began to identify the substances and chemokines that modulated the immune system, oncologists thought to try them for various cancers–perhaps most notably interleukin-2 (IL-2) for melanoma. But these worked in only a subset of patients and caused a whole host of systemic inflammatory symptoms.
Finally, we come to checkpoint inhibitors, first gaining FDA approval in 2011.
Immune checkpoints turn off the immune response (a.k.a. T-cell exhaustion). Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) block checkpoint proteins on immune cells from binding to their targets to activate this checkpoint or pause in immune cell activity. By blocking this pause (“turning off the off switch”), these checkpoint inhibitors keep T-cells “on” and allow them to continue to kill cancer cells. Some cancers have evolved to turn up checkpoint activity surrounding their tumor site to try to evade immune detection.
There are two general types of ICIs. One drug type acts on a checkpoint protein called CTLA-4 (cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated antigen 4), and the others act on checkpoint proteins PD-1 and PD-L1 (programmed death 1 / programmed death ligand 1). By acting to block these interactions, ICIs keep the T-cells active, waking up the immune system against the cancer. (For more, check out a good visual abstract of PD1/PDL1 cell-based interactions on Cancer.gov). In a number of cancers, these checkpoint inhibitors perform better than traditional chemotherapy, without the same hard-to-tolerate side effects.
You may see ICIs used in a number of different cancer types, most notably prostate cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer (triple negative, primarily), colorectal cancer (ones that have high microsatellite instability), lymphomas, and melanoma. Just to name a few –and this list is evolving by the day. It may be easier to identify the cancers where it’s not going to be used than where it is.
The PD-1 targeted ICIs currently available (either commercially or in trials) are cemiplimab, pembrolizumab, and nivolumab (you will likely see pembrolizumab and nivolumab most commonly). The PD-L1 targeted ICIs are atezolizumab, avelumab, and durvalumab. The only CTLA-4 targeted checkpoint inhibitor currently available is ipilimumab (which you will also see somewhat commonly).
Immune checkpoint inhibitors are given via infusion. Infusion reactions to ICIs are quite uncommon. Patients can continue on checkpoint inhibitor therapy for years. But, in revving up the immune system, you can see more auto-immune phenomena, and more inflammation. Dr. Cable frames the possible side effects from ICIs in this context, as the byproducts of inflammation.
ICIs can cause many different immune-mediated conditions. These immune-related adverse events (irAEs) have indirect parallels with rheumatologic autoimmune diseases (with the exception of systemic lupus erythematosus/SLE, which interestingly does not have a parallel checkpoint-induced immune condition).
In addition to rheumatologic and endocrine complications, many organs can be affected (including the liver and the lungs). As Dr. Cable astutely points out, you can inflame anything with the checkpoint inhibitors that you can add an -itis to.
Hypo/Hyperthyroidism: More predominantly hypothyroidism, but hyperthyroidism can also occur (typically subclinical). Can be treated with replacement thyroid hormone or thyroid suppression, and may require longer term treatment, even after checkpoint inhibitor discontinuation.
Diabetes Mellitus: Uncommon, features rapid-onset hyperglycemia with absolute insulin deficiency, and can initially present as diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) in as many as 70% of cases. Because of its rapid onset, the hemoglobin A1c is of limited utility as a screening tool. Tell patients to look out for the symptoms of hyperglycemia, including polyuria and polydipsia, and to let you know if something changes. Patients may require lifelong insulin.
Adrenal Insufficiency: Rare (but slightly more common than DM). Presents with low cortisol and elevated ACTH, elevated renin, as well as typical electrolyte abnormalities. Consider imaging to rule out other adrenal disease and hemorrhage. Replace the missing hormones. (Also consider whether the patient had, prior, been getting exogenous steroids for any particular reason, such as nausea or as part of a chemotherapy regimen).
Sicca Syndrome: Sicca syndrome presents with dry eyes and dry mouth. It is related to Sjogren’s, but is not the same (and does not have the same autoantibody positivity–often negative for anti-Ro and anti-La antibodies). In Sicca syndrome, dry mouth symptoms tend to be more pronounced (Ramos-Casals 2019).
Inflammatory Arthritis: Often polyarthritis or oligoarthritis, with clinical syndromes that are very similar to their rheumatologic parallels, rheumatoid arthritis and spondyloarthritis. Inflammatory markers tend to be elevated, however these arthritides tend to be seronegative–rheumatoid factor and anti-CCP both tend to be negative (in > 90% cases), and also typically negative for HLA-B27. You will see effusions, synovitis, and erosions on imaging (see Calabrese 2018 for more).
Myositis: Very few cases of dermatomyositis, but polymyositis does occur, with sore proximal muscle weakness and diaphragmatic weakness/dysphagia, elevated creatine kinase levels (range 1000-10,000 U/L), sometimes with cardiac involvement and sometimes myasthenia gravis. (Marini 2021; Allenback 2020). Often requires high-dose steroids, and IVIG/plasma exchange in serious cases.
Exclusion Criteria from Trials: Individuals with a personal history of autoimmune disease were excluded from the trials of the checkpoint inhibitors, so we don’t know much about whether checkpoint inhibitors put them at higher risk for irAEs. Consider performance status as well.
Baseline Labs To Check: Before starting ICIs, check routine baseline labs, including a basic metabolic panel, liver function tests, a glucose, a TSH and free T4, and a morning cortisol level. There is not evidence to check auto-antibody levels at baseline.
Timing of irAEs: The earliest irAE to occur is typically dermatitis, with hypothyroidism to follow, with timing a few weeks to a few months. However, it’s important to remember that any of these irAEs can occur at any time, even months to years after a patient received his or her last dose of a checkpoint inhibitor. While many of the non-endocrine complications may go away with steroid treatment, the endocrine complications tend to be lifelong more often.
Ask for Help: Talk to the oncologist who is co-managing the patient with you. They can help with diagnostics and therapeutic tools you may not be as experienced with, for these novel therapeutics. But don’t forget to send your patients early to rheumatology and endocrinology.
Treatment for irAEs: First, stop the checkpoint inhibitor. Second, use the tool of the rheumatologist–steroids (can range from low dose prednisone to mega-dose solumedrol). Treat the endocrine complications as you would, normally, with thyroid, insulin, or adrenal replacement.
Are there risk factors for developing irAEs? Autoimmune disease may be one. There may be genetic risk factors, but we don’t understand them particularly well. And who knows, there may be some microbiome-based differences in susceptibility.
Do I need to have an irAE for the checkpoint inhibitor to be working against my tumor? You don’t need to have side effects of any sort to have the benefit from the checkpoint inhibitor. You can see tumor responses in patients without any irAEs, and treatment outcomes appear to be similar in patients with and without irAEs. The only exception to this appears to be in melanoma, where the presence of vitiligo after ICI initiation appears to correlate with improvement in melanoma. Melanoma-associated vitiligo can occur in patients treated with checkpoint inhibitors, and appears to correlate with higher survival rates in metastatic melanoma.
Will I do as well if I had an irAE? Patients with immune complications who were taken off checkpoint inhibitors did just as well as patients who continued, suggesting that the immune, anti-tumor response, may persist beyond when patients are on the medication and may provide similar benefits even with shorter duration.
Can I restart ICI therapy after an irAE? Many patients will wonder whether or not they can restart checkpoint inhibitors after an immune related adverse event. There’s an approximately 5% risk of having a recurrence of immune symptoms, if you switch classes from a PD1 inhibitor to CTLA4 inhibitor. If you stay in-class, there’s an approximately 50% chance of recurrence, so oncologists prefer not to restart (Haanen, 2020).
For more commonly asked questions, and the latest answers, check out this phenomenal 2018 NEJM review.
Keep an eye out for more about chimeric antigen receptor T-cells, which are cells from a patient’s body that are edited to target a cancer cell. These CAR T-cells can cause cytokine release syndrome, a severe inflammatory syndrome, but they can also cure certain lymphomas and leukemias.
Listeners will be served delicious knowledge food on checkpoint inhibitors, straight from ACP 2022.
After listening to this episode, listeners will…
The Curbsiders report no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Christian Cable reports no relevant financial disclosures.
Taranto NP, Cable C, Heublein M, Williams PN. “#342: Checkpoint Inhibitors”. The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast. http://thecurbsiders.com/episode-list Final publishing date: June 27, 2022.
Got feedback? Suggest a Curbsiders topic. Recommend a guest. Tell us what you think.
We love hearing from you.
Yes, you can now join our exclusive community of core faculty at Kashlak Memorial Hospital along with all the perks:
Close this notice to consent.